Personal civil & criminal liability in copyright software infringement cases
What happens if a company is guilty of intentional, willful and malicious copyright infringement? Obviously the company can be sued in federal court and if illegal copying or pirated software is found a judgment can be entered. But companies can just file for bankruptcy protection right? Well what happens if the software company comes after an officer or a director? Can Plaintiff’s “pierce the corporate veil” or can they just sue the officers and directors for knowingly or recklessly participating in copyright infringement? This blog explores this topic.
When are officers and directors personally liable for copyright infringement?
Some companies mistakenly assume that if a person does not directly participate in a copyright infringement, that they cannot be held personally liable. This is not a correct statement of the law. For example, in Gershwin Pub. Corp. v. Columbia Artists Mgmt., Inc., 443 F.2d 1159, 1161-62 (2d Cir. 1971) the Second Circuit held:
What if a Officer or Director has “reason to know” there is infringing activity occurring?
As the Court noted in Gershwin:
Other Circuits have discussed personal liability for software piracy
Corporate officers are not shielded from suit in their individual capacity when they direct, control, ratify, participate in, or are the moving force behind the infringing activity. See Committee for Idaho’s High Desert, Inc. v. Yost, 92 f.3d 814, 823 (9th Cir. 1996) (company officers who direct and authorize infringing activities can be held personally liable).
What to do if you get a BSA software audit letter and you know you have infringement of Microsoft, Adobe, Autodesk or other copyrighted software?
The first and most important thing is to retain software copyright counsel to assist you. We have handled cases for both copyright holders and Defendants in BSA audits. Before you destroy all your computers and throw them in a lake, call us for advice. You need to retain counsel and have your case reviewed. There may be defenses to copyright infringement available, or issues with the so-called “informant” so we can discuss these with you once retained. In other cases, it comes down to hiring us to apply our strong negotiation skills that we have honed over the last decade as a ciivl litigation law firm.
Can I just discharge my personal liability in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy?
This is a common misconception that any judgement that anyone gets against you in regard to federal software piracy can just be wiped out in bankruptcy. While there is always a chance, this could go either way, and in some instances our legal battles can head into federal bankruptcy Court. We have experience in bankruptcy adversary proceedings (see our Federal Pacer page) and where debts are incurred in bad faith or on other grounds, they might not be automatically dischargeable.
One of the best articles I have read on this topic is “Debts that follow you to the grave.” put out by the American Bar Association. Give this a read. This article states one type of debt that may not be dischargeable in bankruptcy is:
“Willful and malicious injury. Whether an injury to another person or to the property of another person is the result of “willful and malicious” conduct has been the subject of substantial litigation. Both elements are necessary. Willful means that the debtor acted purposefully. Malicious has been defined as knowing that the act is likely to or will cause an injury or harm. The injury or harm does not need to be substantial or severe to fall under the definition of maliciousness; the mere knowledge that the action is likely to cause an injury has generally been deemed sufficient. If the debtor knew what she was doing, did it on purpose, and knew it would probably cause some type of injury or damage, the resulting debt is non-dischargeable.”
We have talked on other blog posts how software companies will assert that copyright infringement or software piracy is “willful” under the Copyright laws, so this is definitely one legal issue that can come into focus in any case involving theft of software.
At what point does intentional copyright infringement by an officer or a director of a company amount to Criminal copyright infringement.
This is also not always an easy test to articulate. Where there is trafficking or distributing copyrighted software (ex. making fake products for Adobe or Microsoft, or Autodesk and trying to sell them online), this would make a pretty clear case for criminal prosecution of the offender and would also warrant a possible raid of the business or even an individuals home using a search warranted granted by a judicial officer. In the case of software licensing shortages (i.e. unpaid software) there are some other tests that might be looked at.
For example, in re U.S.’s Application For A Search Warrant To Seize & Search Elec. Devices From Edward Cunnius, 770 F. Supp. 2d 1138, 1141 (W.D. Wash. 2011) the Court discussed:
“Specifically, criminal copyright infringement includes “willfully infringing a copyright” if that infringement was committed “for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain … by the reproduction or distribution, including by electronic means … of 1 or more copies or phonorecords of 1 or more copyrighted works, which have a total retail value of more than $1,000.” See also 17 U.S.C. § 506(a).
Tips to prevent officers and directors from being name personally for intellectual property theft or infringement
- Adopt and follow policies and procedures relating to software, copyright, and trademark infringement
- Hold frequent meetings to discuss intellectual property issues (document the comments from the meeting)
- Conducting annual software audits
- Consider maintaining a general liability insurance policy that covers intellectual property infringement (sometimes infringement can be purely accidental and innocent, such as the case of hiring a blogger who posts of copyrighted photo on your website, or a consultant that inadvertently installs Microsoft or Autodesk software on your computer networks without a valid license)
- Make sure you are “clearing” all your copyrights, trademarks and “rights of publicity” for all online and offline marketing and advertising.
- Immediately act on all infringement, cease and desist letters, notice of copyright or trademark infringement, and hire legal counsel to discuss your rights, and potentially settle the dispute without having it turn into a federal lawsuit.
- Make sure you are saving all copies, proofs, receipts, email confirmations, for all products your company licenses (this includes videos, film, music, songs, lyrics, comics, jingles, slogans, software products, photographs etc.). The proof of licensing is often your BEST defense.
Contact a copyright software infringement lawyer
To discuss hiring our firm to represent you as Copyright Counsel, call us at (877) 276-5084. We handle both Plaintiff and Defendant cases. We offer flexible legal fees, and tenacious legal representation. Fill out the contact form below for more information or to have one of our Copyright lawyers contact you. Please leave your name and phone number.
Latest posts by Vondran Legal - Business, Real Estate, Insurance, Technology & Civil Litigation Counsel (see all)
- Did your company receive an email about an “Autodesk Software Review” - February 20, 2017
- Malibu Media Lawsuit Updates – Defendant wins! - February 14, 2017
- “Back off buddy” – Intentional interference with prospective economic relations under California law explained - February 1, 2017
- Did Trump sue Alec Baldwin for $445 billion for Copyright Infringement? - January 28, 2017
- ADA Website Accessibility Compliance Litigation on rise in Arizona? - January 25, 2017